← Case studies

Academic Disputes Observatory · Case study

Two failed pharmacy rotations: dismissal upheld on appeal

U.S. Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit · July 2025

The progression rule

A doctoral pharmacy program required students to complete classroom instruction and then pass clinical rotations before graduating. The program handbook set out consequences for course failure, including probation, possible repetition and dismissal after further academic problems. The student at the center of the case had received disability accommodations. Clinical evaluations subsequently identified deficiencies in several areas the program regarded as essential to practice, including attendance, professionalism, clinical reasoning and patient care. The dispute eventually concerned whether those evaluations reflected legitimate performance standards or whether the university had treated the student adversely because of disability.

From probation to dismissal

The academic standing committee placed the student on probation after a failed rotation. The student appealed to the dean and expressed concerns about how she had been evaluated. The program allowed another attempt with a different initial placement arrangement, and the appellate opinion examined who was involved in assigning and supervising the repeat rotation. After another failing evaluation, the committee dismissed her. Through counsel, the student appealed the dismissal and again raised concerns about accommodations and how the assessments had been handled. An acting dean ultimately denied the appeal. The record included the handbook, committee action, clinical evaluations and communications about the student’s accommodation requests.

The court’s inquiry

The student pursued federal disability claims. The appeal concerned the grant of summary judgment on the relevant Rehabilitation Act claim. The appellate court asked whether the evidence, taken in the student’s favor, could allow a reasonable jury to conclude that she was otherwise qualified to remain in the program or that disability accounted for the dismissal. It examined the accommodations the university had provided and the evidence behind the two failed clinical assessments. It found insufficient support for an inference that the decisionmakers assigned the repeat placement to bring about a failure or that the stated academic reasons were a pretext. The court affirmed summary judgment for the university.

What makes the record useful

The opinion treats the internship evaluations as evidence that must be read in context. The accommodations established what support or changes the program had agreed to provide. The evaluation forms explained what performance was observed against the clinical requirements. The committee record connected those observations with probation, repetition and dismissal. Those records answered different questions, even though they concerned the same student. The appellate result turned on the absence of evidence sufficient to support the asserted discrimination inference on this record. It does not establish that every evaluation in a clinical setting is insulated from review or that providing some accommodations resolves every possible complaint. In a comparable dossier, the assignment history and the information actually available to the committee help explain how a judgment about academic progression was made.

Reading the source

The appellate opinion describes the handbook, the repeat placement and the communications surrounding internal appeals before turning to the elements of the disability claim. The court’s analysis concerns whether the evidence would support an inference required for that claim. The chronology and the reasoning are more informative than the bare fact that the university prevailed. The court based its comparison on the actual sequence of evaluations and decisions described in the record.

Source documents

Read the court decision ↗ https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca7-24-01734/pdf/USCOURTS-ca7-24-01734-0.pdf