← Case studies

Academic Disputes Observatory · Case study

Failing graduate project and degree completion · $2 million requested

U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · 2021

The dispute

The student, a graduate student in public health, received a failing grade on a final project and alleged that the assessment prevented him from completing his degree.

The court described the complaint as alleging procedural irregularities in the project’s evaluation and a two-week delay in providing requested records. The student also alleged non-academic misconduct charges after he protested the grade. At the motion-to-dismiss stage, the court described allegations without making findings that they were true.

Arguments and relief sought

The complaint raised multiple legal theories, including discrimination, disability, educational-record rights, contract and freedom of expression. The student sought $2 million. The university moved to dismiss the complaint.

Decision and financial status

On April 1, 2021, the federal district court granted the university’s motion to dismiss. The source identifies distinct reasons and procedural treatment for different claims. The $2 million was requested, not awarded.

Why it matters

The case illustrates how a dispute about a single assessment can be pleaded through several legal theories. The court’s reasoning must be read claim by claim; dismissal does not by itself establish the accuracy of every academic judgment.

The court’s analysis

The court distinguished claims affected by the university’s sovereign immunity from claims it dismissed for failure to state a legal claim. It stated that the contract and First Amendment claims were dismissed without prejudice on immunity grounds; other theories were treated separately. The opinion expressly said that its account of the complaint did not decide whether the allegations were true.

Points to compare

The alleged delayed access to records, the assessment of the project and the later misconduct charge are separate events. The decision does not establish that each of these events occurred as alleged or that every procedural challenge to a grade would fail. Its legal treatment depends on the claims and the defendant before this federal court.

The record in context

The federal opinion states that the student had spent seven years pursuing a master’s in public health when he failed the final project. He asserted that procedures applied differently to him than to other students and that requested records were withheld for approximately two weeks. The court identified these as allegations in the complaint; at that preliminary stage it did not purport to establish their truth. The account also describes a non-academic misconduct charge after his protest, without resolving every factual question surrounding that charge.

The university moved both for dismissal on jurisdictional grounds and for failure to state a claim. The court separated the legal bases instead of treating the complaint as one undifferentiated grade dispute. It concluded that sovereign immunity barred the contract and First Amendment claims against the university and dismissed those claims without prejudice. It addressed the ADA, FERPA, EEOA and civil-rights theories on their own stated grounds.

For comparison, the record illustrates why an alleged grading irregularity, a records request and a misconduct proceeding should be traced separately. A court’s disposition of a legal claim can turn on who is sued, the court’s jurisdiction and the allegations pleaded, as well as on the underlying educational event.

Source documents

Read the source document ↗ https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-mied-3_20-cv-12655/pdf/USCOURTS-mied-3_20-cv-12655-0.pdf