← Case studies

Academic Disputes Observatory · Case study

Failing grade and doctoral-program dismissal · more than $40 million claimed

U.S. District Court, District of Maryland · August 18, 2021

The first course and the failing grade

In fall 2018, the student entered the Organizational Leadership Program at the public university. Her first course involved seven assignments, including written work, a presentation, a group project and a final examination. The federal court’s later memorandum describes a disagreement over the submission and assessment of that work. The student challenged a failing grade and the consequences that followed for her place in the program.

The submission dispute

The opinion reports that the first written assignment was due on September 6, 2018. The student requested permission to submit it the following morning, explaining that she was looking for housing; the instructor denied the request. The court recounts that she later attempted to email the assignment that evening but used an incorrect address. Its account also describes subsequent correspondence about materials the instructor had received. The sequence matters because the parties’ records concerned different parts of the work and different communications; the opinion should be consulted for their details.

Dismissal and internal appeal

The student was informed that she had failed the course and was terminated from the program. She alleged that her grade was arbitrary and challenged the timing of feedback. On October 9, 2018, she appealed the failing grade and requested readmission under the university’s procedure. On December 4, the dean informed her that the university was rescinding her dismissal after reviewing the applicable program policies. The course was treated as a withdrawal and the grade was changed from F to W. The internal reversal did not end the dispute: the opinion records a further appeal after the rescission.

The lawsuit and the amount claimed

The student brought claims against state and federal entities and an accrediting organization. Her complaint included discrimination, due-process, contract, consumer-protection and other theories; the opinion also describes allegations concerning grade tampering and changes. She sought compensatory and punitive damages exceeding $40 million, along with declaratory and injunctive relief. The amount is the plaintiff’s demand across the litigation. It is not an award against the public university, a settlement, a provision or a confirmed institutional cost.

The federal court’s decision

On August 18, 2021, the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland granted the defendants’ motions to dismiss and denied the student’s motions for summary judgment and discovery. The memorandum concluded that the complaint did not state claims on which relief could be granted. Its discussion treats the defendants and legal theories separately, including issues of jurisdiction and immunity. This was a decision on the claims before the court; it was not an academic reevaluation of the student’s work.

Why the sequence is useful

This case makes visible a chain of separate decisions: a disputed submission, a failing course grade, removal from a program, an institutional appeal, rescission of the removal and a later lawsuit. The F-to-W change and reinstatement are institutional actions recorded in the opinion, while the $40 million is a subsequent litigation demand. For a comparable matter, the relevant documents would include the syllabus, submission records, grade communications, appeal policy and the written reasons for the university’s correction. The opinion distinguishes the allegations from its legal conclusions; the cited memorandum alone should not be used to infer a later appellate disposition.

Source documents

Federal court memorandum, August 18, 2021 ↗ https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-mdd-1_20-cv-02213/pdf/USCOURTS-mdd-1_20-cv-02213-0.pdf