← Case studies

Academic Disputes Observatory · Case study

Doctoral capstone credits and program costs · $28.5 million settlement paid

U.S. District Court, District of Maryland · settlement approved 2024

The doctoral-program dispute

Four former students brought a class action in 2022 concerning the university’s online Doctor of Business Administration program. They alleged that the university understated the number of capstone credits students would need to complete the degree, and therefore misrepresented the program’s cost and duration. The capstone phase involved a research and writing project. The dispute concerns program requirements, additional credits and financing; it is not an individual appeal of a course grade.

Allegations and response

The plaintiffs alleged that the challenged practices targeted Black and female prospective students and asserted claims under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, among other legal theories. They sought monetary relief and changes to program practices. The university denied discrimination and denied misrepresenting the capstone requirements, maintaining that it had accurately stated the minimum credits. These positions are recorded in the court-filed settlement materials; they are allegations and defenses, not findings of liability after trial.

The settlement class and dates

The court’s final approval order defines several class groups using race or sex, enrollment dates and whether students were charged for and successfully completed excess capstone credits; some groups also involve student loans or payment plans. The enrollment window runs from August 1, 2008 through January 31, 2018. The lawsuit was filed in 2022 and settled in 2024. Its enrollment history therefore extends before the Observatory’s usual 2018-onward evidence window and is identified here as historical context, not as a measure of disputes arising entirely after 2018.

Settlement and approval

The parties agreed to a $28.5 million settlement fund and specified nonmonetary measures in the agreement. On October 17, 2024, the federal court granted final approval and certified the defined classes for settlement purposes. Approval of a negotiated resolution does not mean the court found after trial that the university committed the alleged discrimination or misrepresentation. The settlement documents explain the eligibility rules, claims process and allocation of funds.

What was paid

In a financial report, the parent company stated that it paid the $28.5 million on November 27, 2024 under the settlement agreement. This establishes the company-reported payment under the agreement. It does not establish that each class member received or redeemed a particular amount. The gross fund covers class-member relief and other approved items, including fees, costs and administration; these components must not be added again to the $28.5 million.

Why the case matters

The central academic issue was the relationship between an announced minimum, the number of credits students ultimately took and the cost of completing the required doctoral project. For a comparable institutional dispute, a reader would want the representations made at enrollment, the catalog and capstone rules then in force, individual progression records, financial terms and any subsequent changes. The court-approved agreement and the corporate disclosure answer different questions: the first sets out the resolution and class; the second reports the company’s payment.

How the fund was structured

The agreement assigns $21.275 million to an escrow account, $7.125 million to an attorneys’ fees account and $100,000 to an administration-cost account. It provides for qualified class members’ shares to be calculated using their excess capstone credits, subject to adjustments described in the agreement. These are the agreement’s allocations within the fund, not separate amounts awarded on top of it.

Source documents

Court order granting final approval, October 17, 2024 ↗ https://walden-dba-settlement.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Walden-Final-Approval-Order.pdfCourt-filed settlement agreement ↗ https://docs.defendstudents.org/news/body/Court-Stamped-Settlement.pdfThe parent company financial report describing payment ↗ https://investors.covista.com/files/doc_financials/2025/q3/a638bcf0-b7d2-45bd-85b0-26e438cb69c5.pdf